Flux-cored Arc Welding (FCAW): Shielding Gases and More

Combining Greater Process Flexibility with the Benefits of Higher Arc Stability

""
What is FCAW Welding?

Flux-cored arc welding (FCAW) uses the heat generated by a DC electric arc to fuse metal in the joint area. The arc is struck between a continuously fed consumable filler wire and the workpiece, melting both the filler wire and the workpiece in the immediate vicinity. The entire arc area is covered by a shielding gas, which protects the molten weld pool from the atmosphere.

FCA welding is widely used in general metal fabrication, structural steelwork, bridge building, pressure vessel and chemical plant construction, and in critical offshore and submarine applications. Because it works well in rugged outdoor environments and tolerates dirty surfaces, FCAW is also a popular welding method for heavy machinery repair in the field. Cored welding is a highly productive process, capable of welding a variety of materials, including plain carbon and alloys steels, mild and structural steels, creep-resisting steels, low-temperature steels as well as austenitic and duplex stainless steels. It can also be used for surfacing and hardfacing.

This flux core welding process is particularly suited to applications where positional welding is required. It is a highly effective welding process as it combines the ability to form a supporting slag for the weld metal - associated with manual metal arc (MMA) welding, also known as stick welding - with the improved duty cycle and the capability to automate the process typical of metal inert gas (MIG) welding operations.

FCAW is a variant of the MIG welding process, and while there are many common features between the two processes, there are also several fundamental differences. FCAW gives welders more flexibility than MIG when they are working with alloy compositions, for instance. It also typically enables higher wire deposition rates and greater arc stability, although the process efficiency of MIG welding is often superior.

Looking to the future, continued advances in flux-cored wires offering new filler wire compositions make FCAW an attractive welding method for an ever-growing range of welding tasks and challenges. New development enabled by digitalization, connectivity, automation and robotic welding systems are also opening up new opportunities for flux core welding.

How Does FCAW Work?

FCA welding uses the heat generated by a DC electric arc to fuse the metal being welded. The arc is struck between a continuously fed consumable filler wire and the workpiece, melting both the filler wire and the workpiece in the immediate vicinity. A wire feed unit takes the filler wire from a spool or bulk pack, and feeds it through the welding gun to the arc. The consumable wire used in FCAW is tubular and contains a core of flux and metal powder. The flux fill is also used to provide alloying, arc stability, slag cover, de-oxidation and - in the case of some wires - gas shielding.

As with MIG - another common arc welding method, direct current power sources with constant voltage output characteristics are normally employed to supply the welding current. With flux-cored wires, the terminal that the filler wire is connected to depends on the specific product being used; some wires running electrode positive, others running electrode negative. The work return is then connected to the opposite terminal. It has also been found that the output characteristics of the power source can have an effect on the quality of the welds produced.

Filler Wires and Transfer Modes in FCAW

FCAW welding uses three types of filler wires: rutile gas-shielded, basic gas-shielded, and self-shielded. Rutile, gas-shielded wires are easy to use with good slag removal and positional capabilities. Basic, gas-shielded wires give better mechanical properties, but tend to be less user-friendly and slag removal can be difficult. Self-shielded wires are ideal for site work but tend to compromise operability and deposition rates as the flux must serve a dual function.

The wire feed unit takes the filler wire from a spool or bulk pack, and feeds it through the welding gun to the arc at a predetermined and accurately controlled speed. Normally, special knurled feed rolls are used with flux-cored wires to assist feeding and to prevent crushing the consumable.

Metal transfer modes with FCAW are similar to those obtained in MIG welding, but here the mode of transfer is heavily dependent on the composition of the flux fill, as well as on current and voltage. The filler metal composition also plays a crucial role in determining transfer characteristics.

The most common modes of transfer in FCAW are:

  • Dip transfer
  • Globular transfer
  • Spray transfer 
Boosting FCAW Productivity - with the Right Shielding Gases

With FCAW, the entire arc area is covered by a shielding gas, which protects the molten weld pool and filler metal against adverse atmospheric effects. This protective atmosphere can be supplied in two different ways:

  • Gas-shielded operation, where a shielding gas is supplied from an external source, such as a gas cylinder
  • Self-shielding operation, where gas is produced as fluxing agents decompose within the wire

Pure carbon dioxide or mixtures of argon (Ar) and carbon dioxide (CO2) are ideal for FCAW auxiliary shielding gas applications. The CO2 composition in argon is typically specified at 20% or 25%. We deliver a range of tried-and-tested cored welding gases with these components under families such as CORGON®, CRONIGON®, VARIGON®, FORMIER® and STARGOLD™. These mixes have been designed to bring you the full benefits of FCAW welding. These include improved productivity combined with high quality across a range of plain carbon, alloy, stainless and duplex steels. Our application experts can advise you on the mixture and operating mode best suited to your needs, also supporting you with the equipment and gas management services you need.

Contact your local Linde representative to check availability in your region.

FCAW vs MIG - Which One is Better?

FCAW is a variant of the metal inert gas (MIG) process. Although there are many common features, there are also several fundamental differences. The main one relates to the consumable. Unlike MIG, which uses a solid consumable filler wire, FCAW uses a tubular consumable where the outer metal sheath is filled with fluxing agents plus metal powder.The flux fill is also used to provide alloying, arc stability, slag cover, de-oxidation, and, with some wires, gas shielding effects. See below for some of the other core similarities and differences.

Similarities between FCAW and MIG welding

  • Both FCAW and MIG can be used manually, automatically and with robots
  • Welding speeds with FCAW and MIG welding are generally similar
  • Both use a continuously fed consumable wire electrode
  • Working with a wire feeder and welding gun, the welder does not need to stop and change rods (unlike stick welding)

Differences between FCAW and MIG welding

  • FCAW is more flexible than MIG welding in relation to alloy composition
  • Deposition rates with flux-cored wires are typically higher than with MIG wires
  • MIG offers greater process efficiency
  • FCAW offers better arc stability and shielding than MIG
  • Unlike MIG welding, FCAW creates a slag cover to protect and support the weld
  • Positional welding can be carried out in spray transfer mode with rutile flux-cored wires whereas MIG can only be performed in dip transfer mode
  • In positional welding, the increased current density reduces the likelihood of 'lack of fusion' defects occurring with FCAW relative to MIG
  • FCAW may be operated with or without a gas shield whereas MIG always requires a shielding gas
  • Self-shielded cored wires are ideal for site work but MIG welding is predominantly a workshop process
  • With gas-shielded flux-cored wires, about 80% of the consumable weight is converted into weld metal; this figure is 65% with self-shielded cored wires and about 98% with MIG
  • Consumable costs are generally much higher with FCAW than with MIG
  • Particulate fume production tends to be higher with FCAW
FCAW vs Stick Welding - the Low-down

Like FCAW, stick welding - also known as manual metal arc (MMA) welding - has the ability to form a slag over the weld metal. This slag supports and shapes the weld bead. FCA welding is typically associated with higher productivity levels than MMA. In addition, flux-cored electrodes can enable a range of metallurgical and physical characteristics that may be difficult or impossible to achieve with traditional stick welding.

Similarities between FCAW and MMA welding

  • MMA electrodes and flux-cored wires cover very similar ferrous, stainless steel and hardfacing materials
  • FCAW using self-shielded cored wires are ideal for work on site; as is MMA welding

Differences between FCAW and MMA welding

  • MMA is predominantly a manual process whereas FCAW can be used manually, automatically or robotically
  • FCAW may be operated with or without a gas shield, whereas MMA never requires a shielding gas
  • Consumable waste is higher with MMA than with FCAW cored wires
  • FCAW enables much quicker welding speeds for faster joint completion times
  • With MMA, only about 65% of the consumable weight is converted into weld metal, compared with around 80% in the case of FCAW
FAQs
What does FCAW stand for?

FCAW stands for flux-cored arc welding. This welding process uses the heat generated by an arc struck between a continuously fed consumable filler wire and the workpiece to fuse the metal in the joint area. It is a popular choice for many different welding applications as FCAW welders can achieve improvements in productivity and weld quality relative to MMA (stick) welding and MIG welding.

What's the difference between FCAW and MIG welding?

FCAW is a variant of the MIG (metal inert gas) process. Common features include the use of a direct current power source with constant voltage output characteristics to supply the welding current. However, MIG uses a solid consumable filler wire whereas FCAW uses a tubular consumable consisting of an outer metal sheath filled with fluxing agents plus metal powder. The flux fill provides alloying, arc stability, slag cover, de-oxidation, and, with some wires, gas shielding effects. The electrical resistance of flux-cored wires is higher than that of solid MIG wires, and this higher electrical resistance gives the FCAW welding method some of its novel properties.

Does FCAW require shielding gas?

With FCA welding, the entire arc area must be covered by a shielding gas to protect the molten weld pool against the effects of atmospheric contamination. This can be achieved in two different ways:

  • A dedicated external shielding gas or gas mixture is supplied from a gas cylinder or similar
  • Decomposition of the fluxing agents within the wire provides a self-shielding effect

Linde offers a wide portfolio of shielding agents tailored to the specific requirements of FCAW.

What shielding gases are most commonly used for FCAW?

The auxiliary shielding gas depends on the specific type of wire used. Pure carbon dioxide (CO2) and mixtures of argon (Ar) and CO2 are most frequently specified for FCAW. Linde offers these gases in different blending ratios to support individual application requirements.

What equipment is needed for FCAW?

The equipment required for the FCAW process is essentially the same as that used in MIG welding, namely a power source, a wire feed system, and a welding gun. In addition, an auxiliary shielding gas is required for gas-shielded operations.

What consumables are best for FCAW?

The right filler metal in FCA welding can help the operator produce welds of high metallurgical and radiographic quality with good mechanical properties, and to overcome typical welding problems such as high hydrogen levels, lack of fusion and porosity, as well as hot or cold cracking defects. Gas-shielded welding wires are available for alloys such as carbon steels, alloy steels, austenitic stainless steels and nickel alloys.

Self-shielded welding wires with filler metal and flux are available for carbon steel and alloy steels. Hardfacing wires depositing weld metal over a wide composition and hardness range are available in gas-shielded or self-shielded versions.

Is FCAW a safe welding method?

Like all welding methods, FCAW can present occupational health and safety issues if best practices are not observed. The extent and nature of these hazards depends on the material being welded and the consumables in use. FCAW does tend to generate more particulate fume than MIG or MMA welding. Whilst most of this fume is considered fairly inert and not a potentially great hazard, some of the metallic and flux constituents of certain products give rise to pollutants which can present a risk to health. These include chromium from stainless steel and some surfacing wires, barium oxide from some self-shielded wires, and high levels of manganese or nickel from some surfacing wires.

Appropriate fume extraction equipment and the correct personal protective equipment (PPE) can mitigate or eliminate these risks. Linde has developed a comprehensive three-level gas portfolio to help welders increase sustainability performance and occupational safety. Building on the proven potential of PPE, organizational change and learning, and technical extraction/purification technologies, this portfolio extends all the way to less-emissive welding gases with the ability to reduce fume emission rates (FER) directly at the source. Click here for more information on our COMPETENCE, PERFORMANCE and PREVENTION Lines.

Looking to improve FCAW operations?

Protect your FCA weld against atmospheric contamination and increase process stability with our FCAW shielding gases.
Contact your local representative